How Pricing Works

Why are snacks at the checkout so expensive?

The hard-hitting investigative journalism I know you want: why a $3.49 bag of Cheez-Its at Michaels is $1.59 at Target. Seven items scanned, six marked up.

Published:

Last Updated

Read Time

5 min read

Maren Kate smiling at the camera in front of houseplants and framed pictures

Written by:

Last Updated

A 3 oz bag of Cheez-It Original crackers hanging below a $3.49 shelf tag at a Michaels checkout.

Price-gouging in the form of tasty, tasty Cheez-Its

On this page

No headings found on page


A few weeks ago I was at Michaels buying some stuff for Halloween and a laundry basket. Of course I used Zozy, which saved me from several overpriced decorations and a tempting storage container that I could get cheaper next door 🤔 Anyways… not the point.

Waiting to check out I started scanning the various food and beverage knick knacks ubiquitous amongst so many big-box checkout lines. What I found was surprising. Every single food package I scanned was priced above what it sells for at 7-Eleven, Walmart or the grocery store.

Here’s what I found: the first price is the Michaels tag; the second is the same bag at Walmart or Target this week.

  • Cheez-It Original, 3 oz: $3.49 at Michaels. $1.59 at Target, $1.54 at Walmart.

  • Flipz milk chocolate pretzels, 7.5 oz: $8.79 at Michaels. $4.77 at Walmart.

  • Dot’s honey mustard pretzels, 5 oz: $7.49 at Michaels. $3.47 at Walmart (seriously—8 bucks for pretzels, in this economy??)

  • Wonderful pistachios, no shells, 2.5 oz: $7.49 at Michaels. $4.48 at Walmart.

  • Lindt Lindor truffles: $9.99 at Michaels. $7.22 at Walmart for the 5.1 oz bag.

  • Wiley Wallaby red licorice: $9.99 at Michaels. $3.69 at Target for the 10 oz bag.

  • Life Savers Gummies, 7 oz: $5.49 at Michaels. $5.99 at Walmart.

So the Life Savers were the exception: Walmart wanted 50¢ more than Michaels did 🤷‍♀️

This got me wondering if Austin's Michaels just likes to squeeze us poor saps as we wait in line, or if this is a bigger pricing issue.

Is food at the checkout really more expensive?

Mostly yes, and the gap depends on what you pick up. The 20 oz sodas are the one place I could find where Michaels and Walmart are basically tied. Coke, Diet Coke and Sprite all list at $2.59 at Michaels and $2.58 at Walmart. Dollar General wants $2.85 for a 20 oz Pepsi. 7-Eleven, the store I assumed would be cheapest, only beats that with its own label: a 7-Select cola launched this month at $1.99 a bottle. I couldn’t find a 7-Eleven price for a plain Coke.

Snacks are a different story. That Cheez-It bag is more than double. The bigger markup, though, is the one hiding in the size, and it isn’t only a Michaels thing. Walmart’s 20 oz Coke comes out to 12.9¢ an ounce. A 12-pack of Coke cans at Publix was $11.99 the same day, about 8.3¢ an ounce. Same drink, half again the price, because you wanted one cold bottle right now instead of twelve cans later. The checkout line is where stores sell you the single.

One gap in all this: nobody publishes a study comparing checkout-line prices with the same item on a shelf, and no store says what a brand pays for the spot by the register. What’s below is what the research does cover, which is what sits there and why.

Why do stores put candy and snacks at the register?

Because people buy them there without planning to, and the stores have known it for decades. Researchers from UC Davis and the University of Illinois Chicago surveyed more than 100 stores in four California cities and logged what sat at checkout: 38% candy, 18% gum, 11% sugary drinks and 9% salty snacks. About seven in ten items in the line counted as unhealthy by the study’s definition. That was California retail, not a craft store, but anyone who has stood in the Michaels line knows the rack looks the same.

Michaels in particular has been at this a long time. Back in 2004 a trade magazine profiled the chain’s candy program, and the buyer in charge had the title senior buyer for party and impulse products. Stores gave at least 16 feet of shelf to front-end candy, most gave 32, and same-store candy sales had just risen 13.5% in a year. A candy bar there cost 79¢. Twenty-two years later the candy is still at the front. The 79¢ is what’s gone.

None of that is a secret or a scandal. A craft store is allowed to sell Snickers. It just means nobody put the snack rack by the register because it’s a good price. The job title Michaels gave its buyer says what it’s for.

How do you avoid overpaying in the checkout line?

Decide before you get there. Everything in that line is aimed at a person who is bored, standing still and already holding a card, which is exactly who I was. The sodas happened to be fair. The Cheez-Its were not, and I’d have had no way to know that from the tag alone.

Two habits cover most of it. First, price the ounce, not the package. A single bottle or a 3 oz bag will usually lose to the 12-pack or the family size, so if you want the thing, buy it where you’d buy the big one. Second, if it wasn’t on your list when you walked in, the line chose it for you. I’m not saying don’t buy things. I’m saying buy what’s right for you, when the price is right, and the checkout rack at a craft store is rarely where the price is right.

Checkout line checklist

  • Scan or look up the price before you grab it. The register is the one spot in the store where the price isn’t sitting next to a competitor’s.

  • Price the ounce, not the bottle. A 20 oz Coke ran 12.9¢ an ounce against 8.3¢ for a 12-pack of cans; the single costs more per ounce.

  • Treat soda as the exception. National-brand 20 oz bottles were within a cent of Walmart; the snacks and candy were the ones to put back.

  • Decide in the aisle, not in the line. If it wasn’t on your list at the door, it’s an impulse product, which is what the store calls it too.

  • Buy the snack where you’d buy the multipack. If you want Cheez-Its, Walmart sells the same 3 oz bag for about $1.50.

Keep reading: Is Costco Actually Cheaper? What a Six-City Study Found and Is it worth paying more? Fair isn’t the same as cheap.

You might also like