Good Deal or Not

Is it worth paying more? Fair isn't the same as cheap

A $5 pricier candle at the boutique, a $10 pricier bottle at Whole Foods. Both can be fair prices once you name what the extra buys you.

Published:

Last Updated

Read Time

7 min read

Maren Kate smiling at the camera in front of houseplants and framed pictures

Written by:

Last Updated

Candles and small decor pieces arranged on a wooden shelf

Half of U.S. shoppers say they'll spend more to shop local, yet 81% name price as what decides where they shop, against 14% for supporting the community.

On this page

No headings found on page


Last month I bought a candle at a boutique near my house for $5 more than that same candle costs on Amazon. I knew it when I paid. One woman opened and runs the shop. I want to support her and her business. So I paid the $5.

Price-wise, that was a bad deal, but for me, it wasn’t.

“Cheap” and “fair” are two different concepts, but most of us only look at the price of something we want.

Is it worth paying more if you can get it cheaper somewhere else?

Yes, when the extra cash gives you something you’d choose on purpose. Cheap is the least cost for a purchase that you want. Fair is paying what the item is worth to you when you consider everything that comes with it. The candle at the boutique and the candle on Amazon are the same, but they aren’t the same purchase. One comes with a shop I can walk into, an owner who remembers what I bought last time, and a street that’s a little better for having her business successfully operating on it. That’s a Fair price. A Cheap price comes in a brown box.

People already think this way. In 1986, Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler phoned hundreds of people in Toronto and Vancouver and asked them to judge prices. A hardware store that raised a $15 snow shovel to $20 the morning after a storm? 82% called it unfair. A grocer who raised lettuce by 30¢ after his own cost went up 30¢? 79% called that acceptable. Same kind of increase, opposite verdict. We don’t judge a price by its size. We judge it by what it brings us.

So the question isn’t “is this the lowest price.” It’s “do I know what the extra is buying, and do I want it?”

What are you paying for when you pay more for convenience?

You’re paying for your own time, and it’s usually a better trade than it looks. Here’s mine. I was headed to a dinner party and wanted to bring a wine I like. Whole Foods had it on sale, and it was still $10 more than Total Wine charges. But Total Wine is across town. I paid the $10.

Run the math. A full-time U.S. worker’s median pay was $1,232 a week in the third quarter of 2026, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. That’s about $30 an hour. A 40-minute round trip across town is $20 of time before you add up the cost of the gas (the IRS puts driving at 72.5¢ a mile in 2026, so call it another $9 for a 12-mile loop). The “cheaper” bottle would have cost me close to $30 in time and driving to save $10. Whole Foods was the cheaper choice if you consider the time it would take me to drive and the cost of that drive.

Convenience fails this test when the time isn’t worth anything to you that day, or when the money is tighter than the minutes. A Saturday with nothing planned changes the answer. So does a month where $10 matters more than 40 minutes. Fair isn’t a fixed number. It depends on what you’ve got more of right now.

Is it worth paying more to support local businesses?

Only if you decide that’s what you’re buying, and then it can be. Half of U.S. shoppers say they’re willing to spend more to shop local, in a 2024 LendingTree survey of 2,000 people. The same survey asked what matters when they choose where to shop: 81% said price, 67% said convenience, and 14% said supporting the community. People say they’ll pay more for local. Then price wins at the register. Is that hypocrisy?

Not really. It’s two different purchases wearing the same label. When I buy printer paper, I’m buying printer paper, and the cheapest one wins. When I buy a candle from her shop, I’m buying the candle and the shop. The boutique thrift store near me is the clearest version of this. Its prices run higher than eBay for the same brands, and I already know that. But eBay doesn’t pour you a coffee, doesn’t have a corner where the good vintage coats hang in the light, and doesn’t have a person at the counter who found the thing you’re holding. I’m paying for the experience. That’s a real product. It just doesn’t have a tag.

The trick is to name it. “I’m paying $5 for the shop” is a fair price. “I guess it’s just more here” is a bad one, even if the number is identical.

When is paying more not worth it?

When you can’t explain what the extra money bought, then it’s just not worth paying more.

This test catches the sale that isn’t one. A “compare at” price on a tag or a crossed-out number online tells you nothing about what the item sells for today, so a price that’s higher than elsewhere, dressed as a markdown, isn’t a convenience premium or a local premium. It’s just more. It also catches the premium you didn’t choose. Would you drive across town if you knew the price was $25 instead of $10? You didn’t buy convenience; you bought without knowing. In that LendingTree survey, 31% of people said they feel guilty ordering from Amazon, and of the 29% who said they’re morally opposed to it, 85% still shop there. Paying more because you feel bad isn’t fair either. It’s a fine you charged yourself.

Here’s the flip side. If the thing is the same, the base price is the going price, and the extra buys you nothing you’d pay for on its own, then cheap and fair are the same answer. Go cheap. There’s no virtue in a higher price with nothing else to recommend it.

How much more is reasonable to pay?

There’s no percentage of how much more you could pay for an item without feeling stupid, and anyone who gives you one is averaging strangers. Surveys try. One from Empower in late 2024 found that the people willing to pay more at a local store would pay about $14 more on average. Morgan Stanley’s research puts the convenience premium at around 5%. Those are fine as a sanity check and useless as a rule, because they’re about someone else’s afternoon and someone else’s street.

What works better is three questions, asked in order. First, what’s the going price for this exact thing right now? Not the “was” price, not the price on the tag. The price other people are paying today. You can’t judge a premium until you know what it’s a premium on. Second, what will the extra buy me? Say it in words. Time, a person, a room, having it in my hand tonight? Third, would I pay that amount for that thing if it were sold separately? Would I hand the owner $5 as a thank-you? Would I pay $10 to get 40 minutes back? If yes, the price is fair, whatever Amazon charges. If no, you’ve got your answer too.

The $5 candle passed. The $10 bottle passed. I’ve also put things back at that same boutique, at prices $20 over what I could get online, because when I asked what the extra was buying, the answer was “a bigger candle.” She didn’t mind. I’ll be back next week.

Before you pay more: a quick test

  • Find the going price first. Search the exact item and see what it sells for today, not what the tag says it used to cost.

  • Subtract. Know the real gap in dollars, not a feeling that it’s “a bit more here.”

  • Name what the extra buys: time, driving, having it now, the owner, the room, the coffee? If you can’t name it, don’t pay it.

  • Price the alternative in full. Count the round trip in minutes and miles, and the days you’d wait for a box.

  • Ask whether you’d buy that extra on its own. If you’d tip the owner $5, the $5 is fair. If you wouldn’t, it isn’t.

  • What do you have more of today: money or time? The fair answer changes with it.

  • Don’t pay for guilt. A premium you can name is a choice. One you can’t is just a higher number.

You might also like