How Pricing Works
Are Black Friday Deals Real? What Price Tracking Shows
Discounts move by day and category, let's learn how to check if it's a real deal, before you buy on Black Friday.

Consumers' Checkbook found that at 21 of 25 national chains, at least half the items it tracked were on "sale" more than half the time.
Last Black Friday, TVs were marked down about 24% on the big retail sites.
But… three days later, on Cyber Monday, the same category was about 22% off. Sounds like the deals were real. But WalletHub tracked 3,100 Black Friday items last year and found that 36% of them cost the same as they had in the three weeks before the sale. Another 9.5% cost more 🫢.
Which begs the question—what’s the deal with Black Friday “deals”?
Is the Black Friday sale real or fake?
Most Black Friday markdowns are real discounts off the price from a few weeks earlier, but - most importantly - roughly a third aren’t. That’s the shape of every study that’s tracked it. WalletHub’s 2025 analysis compared advertised Black Friday prices for 3,100 items against prices between Oct 27 and Nov 17. It found 64% of items had a real markdown, averaging about 24% off. The rest offered no savings at all.
The tougher test is to look further back than three weeks. Visualping, a price-alert company, tracked 2,620 products at nine Canadian retailers, Amazon, Best Buy, Canadian Tire and Staples among them, every day from Oct 1 through Cyber Monday 2025, and compared each Black Friday price with the lowest price it had seen since October. One in three Black Friday prices was higher than a price the same item had already sold for that fall, by 37% on average. A 15-inch MacBook Air was $1,449 Canadian on Black Friday at Amazon, which sets its own price for Apple products. It had been $1,337 in early November.
So the sale is real in the narrow sense. The price did drop from last week. It’s fake in the sense that matters to you, which is whether this is the lowest you could’ve paid.
Why do so many sale prices not count?
Because the “was” price the discount is measured against is often not a price anything sold for. Consumers’ Checkbook, a nonprofit that takes no advertising, tracked sale prices at 25 national chains for 24 weeks in 2025, checking 25 to 30 items per store every week. At 21 of the 25 chains, at least half the items were on “sale” more than half the time. The ten worst offenders had most of their tracked items on sale always or almost always. Only three chains, Apple, Costco and Dell, ran discounts Checkbook called consistently legitimate, meaning their sale labels matched a real regular price, not that every price was a low.
When a sweater is 40% off for 20 weeks out of 24, the 40% isn’t a markdown. It’s the price. Black Friday takes that habit and adds a countdown clock. Both countries have a rule against it. The FTC’s guides on deceptive pricing say a former price counts only if it’s the actual price the item was offered at, on a regular basis, for a reasonably substantial period, and that an inflated price set up so a big reduction can follow makes the bargain a false one. Canada’s Competition Bureau puts it as two tests: more than half of sales at that price or higher, or the item offered in good faith at that price for a substantial period, usually within a year. Last November it said plainly that advertising “$100, now $50” is illegal if the item never sold at $100. The rules exist. Checkbook’s numbers show how often they’re ignored.
What does that mean for you? Ignore the percentage on the sign. It’s measured against a number the store chose. The only reference price that counts is what the item sold for recently.
Is it cheaper to shop on Black Friday?
On average, yes. For the item in your cart, maybe. Adobe measures discount rates across the biggest US retail sites, and its 2026 holiday forecast expects discounts of up to 14% off list in early November, up to 21% just before Thanksgiving, up to 30% during Cyber Week and 10% to 15% through December. (Adobe sells the analytics software those retailers run, so it has no reason to understate the sale.) That curve is real. If you buy a random mix of things on Black Friday, you’ll pay less on average than in October or December.
But you don’t buy a random mix. You buy one TV. And the item-level data shows that the average hides the thing you care about: one in three of the specific items Visualping tracked had already sold for less that fall, and WalletHub found 36% of its 3,100 items with no savings at all. Black Friday is the best average day. It’s often not the best day for the exact item you want.
Is it better to buy on Black Friday or Cyber Monday?
It depends on the category, and the gap is small. Adobe’s 2025 numbers put electronics at about 29% off on Black Friday and 31% off on Cyber Monday. Toys went the other way: about 30% off on Black Friday, 28% on Cyber Monday. Apparel sat near 25% both days. TVs were 24% off on Friday and 22% on Monday.
For 2026, Adobe expects electronics and computers to bottom out on Cyber Monday, Nov 30, and TVs, toys, apparel, appliances and furniture to hit their lowest on Black Friday, Nov 27. The forecast peaks are electronics 30% off listed price, toys 29%, TVs, computers and apparel 23%, sporting goods 19%, appliances and furniture 18%. Sporting goods are expected to be cheapest on Thanksgiving itself. Two or three percentage points between the days is $5 on a $200 item. A holiday-only model number, or a “was” price nobody paid, can cost you a lot more than that. Pick the day by category if you like, but the item is where the money is.
Does Amazon or Best Buy have better deals on Black Friday or Cyber Monday? Both stores now treat the two days as one stretch. Amazon’s Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday event runs Nov 19 to 30, and Amazon says new deals will drop twice on both days, at midnight and 8 a.m. Pacific. Best Buy’s published schedule runs a Black Friday sale Nov 19 to 28 and a Cyber Monday sale Nov 29 to 30, with new doorbusters each Friday. Neither store says which day a given item will be cheapest, and a new deal dropping at 8 a.m. doesn’t mean the item you were watching got cheaper. So for a specific item, the day tells you less than its price history does. The next section covers how to check it.
Will things be cheaper if you wait past Cyber Monday? Not usually. In the first week of December 2025, Adobe’s discount rates came down from their peaks: toys to 23%, computers to 20%, electronics and TVs to 19%, apparel to 18%, and furniture, appliances and sporting goods to 15%. For most categories the low is one of the two days, not the week after.
How do you check whether a Black Friday price is a real discount?
Look at what the item sold for in the last month, not at the sign. For anything sold on Amazon, a price-history tracker like CamelCamelCamel or Keepa shows a chart of past prices. If the line is flat and the “deal” sits on it, there’s no discount. If the line dropped to the same level in July, you’re looking at a normal sale with a holiday label.
For other stores, build your own history. Starting now, three to four weeks out, screenshot the price of the few things you plan to buy. That’s the same window WalletHub used, and it’s enough to catch the two most common tricks: a price that goes up in early November so it can come down on the 27th, and a sale price that’s simply the everyday price with a red tag.
Check the model number too. Holiday electronics are sometimes made for the sale, with a slightly different model number and slightly less inside. The price history for the model you were watching tells you nothing about the one on the shelf. (The general method for sizing up any price, in a store or online, is in our guide to whether a price is a good deal.)
Is it worth buying things on Black Friday?
Yes, when three things line up: you were going to buy it anyway, the category is one where discounts get deep, and the price history says this is at or near the low. Electronics and toys have the deepest holiday markdowns in Adobe’s data, around 30%. Furniture, appliances and sporting goods sit closer to 18% to 20%.
It’s not worth it when the deal is only the countdown. A 24% discount off a price that was raised three weeks ago is 0% off. A “Final Sale” sticker that’s been on the rack since spring is the price. Something you didn’t need in October is not cheaper because it’s 30% off in November. It’s $140 you weren’t going to spend.
Before you buy on Black Friday: a checklist
Screenshot the price of anything you plan to buy three to four weeks before Nov 27, and compare the sale price to that, not to the “was” or “compare at” number on the tag.
On Amazon, check the price-history chart. A flat line means no discount. A dip to the same price earlier in the year means it’ll be back.
Match the model number exactly. A holiday-only model number is a different product.
If a store has had the item “on sale” for months, the sale price is the real price. Compare it elsewhere.
Skip anything you only want because of the countdown. The deal on a thing you didn’t need is 100% of the price.
You might also like



