Shopping In Person
Is Costco Actually Cheaper? What a Six-City Study Found
Shelf prices ran 21.4% below Walmart in a six-city study. The catch is the 5.5-pound bag of apples, and the math on the $65 card.

In Consumer Reports' six-city price check, Costco's grocery basket came in 21.4% below Walmart's.
A 5.5-pound bag of Gala apples at Costco for $8.79. The same apples at Kroger for $2 a pound. Per pound, Costco wins by 20%. Now eat 3.5 pounds and let the other two go soft in the fridge. You just paid $2.51 a pound, and Kroger was cheaper. So is Costco actually cheaper? On the shelf, yes, and by a wide margin. In your kitchen, it depends on what you throw away. Here’s what the measured studies say, where the warehouse loses, and how to run the math before you pay.
Do you actually save money by going to Costco?
Yes, if you’re comparing shelf prices. The biggest recent check is Consumer Reports’ Most and Least Expensive Supermarkets, published in February 2026. A retail research firm, the Strategic Resource Group, walked store aisles in six metro areas in late summer 2025 and priced baskets of packaged goods, produce and meat, each city inside a 48-hour window. Sale prices and loyalty-card discounts counted; coupons and app-only deals didn’t. Walmart was the baseline.
Costco came in 21.4% below Walmart on the national average. BJ’s Wholesale Club was right behind at 21% below. Then came Lidl and Aldi, each about 8% below Walmart, and WinCo at 3%. On the other end, Target ran about 6% above Walmart, Trader Joe’s 25% above and Whole Foods nearly 40% above. (Sam’s Club wasn’t in the comparison.)
Two caveats come from the study itself. The baskets weren’t the same size everywhere, because not every store carries the same items (56 items against Target, 23 against Trader Joe’s in Chicago). And the comparisons were, in Consumer Reports’ words, most robust for retailers carrying identical national brands. Costco sells a lot of Kirkland. So treat 21.4% as the right order of magnitude, not a number you’ll see on every receipt.
Why is Costco cheaper?
Because Costco makes its profit on the membership card, not on the groceries. In its annual report for the year ending August 2025, Costco says its volumes and turnover let it “operate profitably at significantly lower gross margins (net sales less merchandise costs) than most other retailers.” The filing puts that gross margin at about 11% of sales.
The other half of the model is the fee. Costco had 81 million paid members at the end of fiscal 2025, and 92.3% of members in the US and Canada renewed. Executive members, who pay for the higher tier, accounted for 73.6% of worldwide sales. The fees are nearly pure profit, so the store can price the goods close to cost. It also limits most items to the fast-selling sizes, by design, which is why you can’t buy a single can of anything.
Is a Costco membership worth it?
Usually, yes, and the break-even is lower than most people guess. Costco’s filing lists the US Gold Star fee at $65 a year. Apply Consumer Reports’ 21.4% gap and you’d need to shift about $300 of Walmart-priced groceries a year to Costco to save $65. That’s $25 a month. Most households clear it in one trip. (The Canadian fee differs; check costco.ca.)
The Executive tier costs another $65, so $130 a year, and pays a 2% reward on qualified purchases, capped at $1,250 a year. The extra $65 pays for itself at $3,250 of annual spending, or about $270 a month. Below that, the upgrade loses money. Above it, every dollar you spend returns 2¢.
The fee isn’t the risk. The risk is what the fee does to your behavior. Once you’ve paid $65, every trip feels like it should justify it, and a run for paper towels ends with a $300 receipt. Save 21% an item and buy a third more items, and you’ve spent more, not less. The math only works if your list stays the same length.
Is Costco cheaper than any grocery store?
No. It’s cheaper than most on most items, and the gap shrinks or flips on exactly the things people warn you about. In a deals site’s 50-item price check against Kroger, updated in 2025, Costco won 43 items, Kroger won four, and three were ties. The ties were boneless chicken breast, red grapes and onions, all at the same price per ounce. Kroger beat Costco on vine tomatoes (by 36%), on the identical 5-pound bag of store-brand frozen vegetables ($5.69 to Costco’s $7.49), and on pasta sauce, where Costco’s three-jar pack cost more per ounce than one jar. A separate check of 90 items in May 2025, run for a lender’s blog, found Costco’s smallest savings on New York strip (8%) and beef burgers (3%), and its biggest on croissants, cereal and candy.
The pattern holds across checks: packaged and baked goods are where Costco wins big, fresh meat is close, and produce depends on the week. Aldi and Lidl sit within 13 points of Costco in Consumer Reports’ study with no fee at all, so a list that’s mostly produce and basics may do better at a discount grocer once you count the card.
Delivery flips everything. Costco says its same-day prices are higher than the warehouse to cover Instacart’s fees, which we went through in our post on whether Instacart prices are higher than in store. The 21.4% is a shelf number.
Is the bigger package really cheaper?
Only if you use it. This is the unit-price trap, and the apples at the top are the clean version of it. Costco’s bag is 20% cheaper per pound, but it costs $8.79 out the door versus $4 for two pounds at Kroger. The per-pound win survives only if you eat more than 4.4 of the 5.5 pounds. Waste a fifth of the bag and it’s a tie. Waste more and Kroger was cheaper.
That’s not a hypothetical. The EPA estimates that food waste costs American consumers about $728 a person a year, or $2,913 for a household of four, using 2023 retail prices. A 40-ounce tub of spinach is a bet on your week, and the unit price on the tag assumes you win it. So for anything that spoils, divide the Costco price by the amount you’ll finish before it turns, then compare that number to the regular store. For anything that keeps (paper goods, rice, detergent, frozen food you’ll rotate through), the tag’s unit price is the real one and Costco almost always wins.
Is Costco cheaper for TVs and tires?
Competitive, with extras that matter more than the sticker. Consumer Reports’ TV testers found Costco’s prices very competitive with other major retailers, sometimes marginally higher, and often paired with a longer warranty: Costco extends the manufacturer’s TV warranty to two years and allows returns for 90 days, where Best Buy’s standard window was 15. One catch: the Costco model number usually differs from Best Buy’s by a letter or two, so a price-match search won’t find the twin. (That review was last updated in 2023, so check the current return window before you buy.)
Tires are the clearest non-grocery win, though not on price. In Consumer Reports’ survey of more than 24,500 members who bought tires, run in fall 2024, Walmart had the lowest tire prices and still landed at the bottom of the satisfaction rankings, alongside Pep Boys and Mavis. Costco tied for the least expensive installation and earned top or near-top marks for free perks. For furniture and appliances, we found no measured comparison worth citing, so read the tag the way you’d read the apples: the price of what you’ll actually use, plus whatever the store throws in.
Before you pay at Costco
Divide the price by the amount you’ll finish before it spoils, not the amount in the package, and compare that number to your regular store.
Run the break-even once a year: at a 21% gap, a $65 card pays off after about $300 of groceries, and the $130 Executive card only after $3,250 of spending.
Buy shelf-stable and frozen goods in bulk, and check fresh meat and produce item by item, where the gap shrinks or flips.
Compare the installed or warrantied price on tires and TVs, with the perks, the two-year coverage and the 90-day return counted, not the sticker alone.
Treat delivery as a different store, because Costco’s same-day prices are marked up on purpose and the shelf discount stays in the warehouse.
You might also like



