Shopping Online

Are Instacart prices higher than in store?

A dozen eggs: $2.89 on the shelf, $3.39 in the app, before fees. Who sets Instacart prices, how wide the gap runs, and when it's worth paying.

Published:

Last Updated

Read Time

5 min read

Maren Kate smiling at the camera in front of houseplants and framed pictures

Written by:

Last Updated

Paper bags of groceries with fruit, vegetables and bread

Costco says its same-day delivery prices are higher than the warehouse to cover the fees Instacart charges.

On this page

No headings found on page

A dozen store-brand eggs at a Hannaford in Maine last December: $2.89 on the shelf, $3.39 in the Instacart app. Same store, same eggs, same week. And that’s before the service fee, the delivery fee and the tip. So is Instacart more expensive than walking in? Usually, yes, but not always, not by a fixed amount, and not always for the reason you’d guess.

Are Instacart prices higher than in store?

Often, yes, and Instacart says so itself. Its help center states that “some retailers may set prices on the Instacart platform that are different than in-store prices.” When a Maine TV station checked four staples at two grocery chains in December 2025, every item cost more in the app at Hannaford. Eggs were 50¢ more, milk 81¢ more, butter 50¢ more. At Shaw’s, most items cost more and one, a store-brand peanut butter, was $2.99 in both places. The full bill ran more than 12% higher on Instacart, with no fees counted.

That’s one small check at two stores in one week, not a national average (nobody has published one). What it does show is the pattern: the app price and the shelf price are two separate numbers, and you can’t assume they match.

Who sets the prices on Instacart?

The store does, mostly. Instacart’s help center puts it plainly: “Retailers set the item prices on the Instacart marketplace.” Some stores match their shelf prices. Some add a markup to cover what they pay Instacart. And some don’t hand over their prices at all.

Target is the example that came out last year. When reporters asked, Target said it doesn’t share its pricing with Instacart. Instacart then acknowledged that it pulls Target’s public prices itself and adds an amount for its own “operating and technology costs.” Instacart says it works with retailers to line up online and in-store prices “wherever possible.” Which means sometimes it isn’t possible, or isn’t done.

So the real question isn’t whether Instacart is expensive. It’s what your store charges through Instacart, and that changes from one store to the next.

How much more does Costco cost on Instacart?

More than the warehouse, by Costco’s own description. Its Same-Day page says item pricing “is higher than your local warehouse in order to cover the service and delivery fees charged by Instacart,” with a $35 order minimum. Costco doesn’t say how much higher.

The best measured number is old. In 2018, Consumer Reports bought the same nine fresh-food items in a Costco warehouse near Yonkers and through same-day delivery. Individual items ran 24% to 46% higher delivered, and the basket cost 31% more: $112.33 against $85.62. That test is eight years old, so I wouldn’t lean on the exact percentages. The disclosure is current, though: at Costco, the markup is built in on purpose.

Do different shoppers see different prices on Instacart?

They did, until last December. In September 2025, Consumer Reports, the Groundwork Collaborative and More Perfect Union had hundreds of volunteers load the same carts at the same stores at the same time. In the report published December 9, 74% of items showed different prices to different shoppers. The average gap between the lowest and highest price was 13%, and some shoppers paid up to 23% more for the same item. One dozen eggs at a Safeway in D.C. showed up at five prices, from $3.99 to $4.79. Whole baskets differed by about 7%.

The prices came from tests that retailers ran through Instacart’s Eversight pricing software. Within two weeks, the FTC had reportedly asked Instacart for information about it, and on December 22 Instacart said retailers could no longer run item price tests on its platform. It said the tests “missed the mark for some customers.”

That doesn’t mean everyone sees the same price now. Stores still set their own Instacart prices, and those can differ from the shelf. (If personalized pricing is new to you, we wrote about how it works in why your price might not be my price.)

What do the fees add to an Instacart order?

Enough to matter more than the markup on a small order. On top of item prices, Instacart charges a service fee, often a delivery fee, and asks for a tip. When the FTC sued Instacart, it said the service fee could add up to 15% of the order and that “free delivery” ads didn’t make that clear. In December 2025, Instacart agreed to pay $60 million in refunds and to stop misrepresenting delivery costs. The settlement covered those claims and subscription sign-ups, not item prices.

Item prices may be next. In April 2026 the FTC asked for public comment on a possible rule for delivery apps, and one question on its list is whether app prices are “the same as, or different from” in-store prices. Nothing has been decided. For now, nothing requires the app to show you the shelf price.

When is Instacart still worth the extra?

When the extra buys you something you’d pay for on its own. If the trip to the store costs you an hour you don’t have, or you can’t drive, or you’re home with a sick kid, 12% plus fees can be a fair price for the groceries showing up at your door. We made the case for paying more on purpose in is it worth paying more? Same test here: can you name what the extra is buying?

What doesn’t pass the test is paying the gap without knowing it’s there. A $3.39 dozen of eggs isn’t a problem. A $3.39 dozen you think costs $2.89 is.

Before you order groceries on Instacart

  • Pick the store, then check how it prices. Look for a note under the store name or in the item details saying whether prices match the shelf.

  • Spot-check three items you buy every week. Compare the app with your last receipt or the store’s own site.

  • If the store has its own delivery or pickup, price the same cart there. Some stores match their shelf prices on their own apps.

  • Add up the whole order: items, service fee, delivery fee and tip. Compare that total with the in-store cart, not just the item prices.

  • Bigger orders spread the fees thinner. Several small orders a week are the most expensive way to use it.

  • At Costco, assume every item is marked up. It’s disclosed.

  • Decide what the convenience is worth before you check out, not after.

You might also like